Skip to content
Flux Collective

The Collapse of the 28-Point Peace Proposal for Ukraine: Why Diplomatic Efforts Continue to Falter

Europe breathed a deep collective sigh of relief on Monday, as the diplomatic emergency caused by the announcement of a new comprehensive peace framework for ending the war appeared – momentarily – to have been stabilised. A American diplomat spoke of "significant advancement" after bilateral negotiations in Geneva. On Monday night, Moscow made its response: a renewed assault of rocket attacks on Kyiv.

The Pattern of Peace Talks and Military Action

The succession of opposing developments captured the harsh reality of the outgoing year. By day, political struggles are fought: hopeful statements are delivered from various governments. Considerable effort is expended on restraining certain initiatives. By night, Russian leadership brutally reminds the world that, for them, war remains the key method for achieving "settlement".

Nocturnal Warfare

As military strikes developed into the early hours of Tuesday, the immediate reality of Ukraine's vulnerability was laid bare. Ukraine is equipped to monitor projectile deployments from Russian territory, a capacity provided through timely intelligence. From observation points, Ukrainian air force fighter jets that had been deployed to engage hostile guided weapons roared overhead – advanced fighter aircraft supplied to Ukraine by NATO members.

Moments later, Kyiv's air-defence systems thundered: defensive missiles deployed against a Russian ballistic missile. This was a modern interception technology at work, probably supplied through partner states. Every firing shakes the surroundings, causing tremors. The instant of fear quickly becomes resigned acknowledgment: possibly the hostile projectile won't cause damage this time, sparing the city from ruin and additional electricity failures.

Persistent Threats

Soon after, a heavy machine gun opened up on a aerial vehicle somewhere nearby, part of a rapid response unit – most likely allied-provided weaponry. Regrettably, the projectiles didn't strike the hostile drone – it pressed on overhead toward its objective.

Periodically, this persisted until dawn. Kyiv awoke to the early updates: seven people killed, destruction and utility failures in numerous residences as a result of the night's assault. As always, everyone still went about their day – experiencing conflict. But those entire period illustrated Ukraine's essential dependence on Western support – a need that neighboring countries are demonstrably unable to fill in the near term.

Failed Diplomacy

The detailed framework from American leadership generated strong feelings, discussion and serious worry – and temporarily diverted attention from Ukraine's largest corruption scandal in years. Yet, we have seen this script before, after earlier high-level meetings and international summits.

Every new approach from Washington unfolds according to the consistent cycle: a political offensive against Ukraine, which Kyiv, with other European capitals, manages to fend off. They contain the crisis but never actually secure success. This trend will, no doubt, endure.

Tactical Assessments

It is easy to blame particular leaders of repeatedly advocating Moscow's conditions. But that does not seem to be the whole story. US administration works based on a premise well known to international relations experts: you cannot achieve through diplomacy what you have lost on the battlefield. The American government believes that it is impossible to force Russia to relinquish the territory that it presently holds in Ukraine's occupied territories.

The issue is that while accepting these circumstances, American administration does minimal to discourage Russia, through statements or actions, from assuming that the status quo will not evolve additionally in its advantage in the months ahead.

Divergent Views

Therefore, Russian leadership is confident that duration works to their advantage – that Ukraine and its allies are coming close to fatigue. Their reason to sign a deal that does not give them the maximum possible gain is virtually nonexistent. There may be numerous efforts to stop fighting, but they will carry on as long as Russia's leadership remains highly assured in the result.

On the contrary, Kyiv believes that Ukraine can still hold out, slowly losing civilians and areas but avoiding a complete military breakdown until situations evolve in its favour.

Current Realities

Objectively, there are no genuine requirements for a armistice. Now, personal considerations are becoming relevant: political desires to negotiate peace and secure international recognition, and the government's twin challenges – on one hand, not to alienate a key ally, and on the other, to unite the population around the flag against any initiative Kyiv finds unsuitable, so that their priority does not switch to domestic problems. And although their objective will now be much harder after current events, it remains quite doubtful that this will modify their basic position.

These opposing factors are driving the talks.

Summary and Prospects

It took a only one week to kill the proposed articles of the current initiative. Assertive and inconsistent approach of the matter by American leadership, opposition by Ukraine and the rest of Europe, along with calming attempts of negotiators, and finally, current information leaks, all achieved their purpose.

While new initiatives based on established approaches are approaching, Kyiv, London and other allied nations should reach an essential realization: Ukraine and Europe will only be able to fend off negotiation assaults from Washington that are based on Russian demands and reflect particular unwillingness to modify developments, if they maintain solidarity and improve their protective measures at a significantly accelerated rate. If they do, no combination of diplomatic or military actions will be able to defeat them. In the meantime, Ukraine's capacity to counter nocturnal attacks will, for the foreseeable future, largely rely on sustained allied backing.

BS
The writer

Bruce Stanton

A tech strategist and writer with over a decade of experience in digital transformation and startup ecosystems across Europe.

Flux Collective

Type to search articles.